Stock Market News
Sainsbury's Asda deal too risky for JP Morgan, but Merrill's a fan
There are too many uncertainties hanging over Sainsbury's proposed acquisition of Asda to justify the price and Tesco is a better bet, JP Morgan analysts said.
Sainsbury's agreed purchase of Asda from Walmart, comprising £3bn cash plus shares, could be a good deal for both sides, the analysts said. But, after Sainsbury's shares rose 15% following the announcement, the price assumes the deal is low-risk when it isn't, they said.
The assumptions include:
The deal gets regulatory clearance
The combined company will not be forced to dispose of stores
Management executes the deal with no mistakes
Management achieves the target of £500m synergies by 2022
There is no certainty the Competition & Markets Authority will approve the deal and if the CMA requires store disposals there are no obvious takers, JP Morgan said.
Timing is also an uncertainty because a full CMA inquiry could take 15-18 months, according to the analysts, who kept their 'underweight' rating for Sainsbury's and increased their price target to 260p a share from 200p.
Tesco, whose takeover of Booker has been approved by the CMA, is a better bet for investors, JP Morgan said.
"We would rather buy Tesco, where there is no CMA risk, there is a new addressable market/avenue of growth and the combined businesses are in better shape."
Taking a more bullish view of the deal, Bank of America Merrill Lynch rebooted its coverage of Sainsbury with a 'buy' rating as analysts said the £500m target for deal synergies as credible, leading to earnings per share improvements of at least 40% the third year after.
"We believe announcement of the Asda deal will erode the long-term discount Sainsbury has faced versus the market as it is taken more seriously as a competitor willing to take action for survival," Merrill said, sticking a 350p price target on the shares.
Based on forecast 2019 earnings, Sainsbury's shares are changing hands for a 4.4% discount to the sector average on a standalone basis, while a blue sky scenario assuming £230m synergies by 2021 would mean the shares are trading for just 10.9 times 2021 earnings, versus peers at 13.4 times.
At 1600 BST, Sainsbury's shares were up 1.5% to 313.50p and Tesco was down 0.5% to 234.80p.
Sainsbury's agreed purchase of Asda from Walmart, comprising £3bn cash plus shares, could be a good deal for both sides, the analysts said. But, after Sainsbury's shares rose 15% following the announcement, the price assumes the deal is low-risk when it isn't, they said.
The assumptions include:
The deal gets regulatory clearance
The combined company will not be forced to dispose of stores
Management executes the deal with no mistakes
Management achieves the target of £500m synergies by 2022
There is no certainty the Competition & Markets Authority will approve the deal and if the CMA requires store disposals there are no obvious takers, JP Morgan said.
Timing is also an uncertainty because a full CMA inquiry could take 15-18 months, according to the analysts, who kept their 'underweight' rating for Sainsbury's and increased their price target to 260p a share from 200p.
Tesco, whose takeover of Booker has been approved by the CMA, is a better bet for investors, JP Morgan said.
"We would rather buy Tesco, where there is no CMA risk, there is a new addressable market/avenue of growth and the combined businesses are in better shape."
Taking a more bullish view of the deal, Bank of America Merrill Lynch rebooted its coverage of Sainsbury with a 'buy' rating as analysts said the £500m target for deal synergies as credible, leading to earnings per share improvements of at least 40% the third year after.
"We believe announcement of the Asda deal will erode the long-term discount Sainsbury has faced versus the market as it is taken more seriously as a competitor willing to take action for survival," Merrill said, sticking a 350p price target on the shares.
Based on forecast 2019 earnings, Sainsbury's shares are changing hands for a 4.4% discount to the sector average on a standalone basis, while a blue sky scenario assuming £230m synergies by 2021 would mean the shares are trading for just 10.9 times 2021 earnings, versus peers at 13.4 times.
At 1600 BST, Sainsbury's shares were up 1.5% to 313.50p and Tesco was down 0.5% to 234.80p.
Related share prices |
---|
Sainsbury (J) (SBRY) share price |
Tesco (TSCO) share price |
Stock News headlines are gathered from financial news sources around the web. Views and opinions on each item are from their respective authors and website. They are not opinions of LiveCharts.co.uk
Get a free widget for your website with our latest headlines.
You can now add our live prices and new headlines to your website.The news widget features quotes for Oil prices, spot Gold price and Indices plus a choice of news channel for healines.
Top Shares pages
- Share price quotes
- Share charts
- Share watch list
- Company Results Calendar
- Top Large UK Shares
- UK Market Sectors
- Stock market news
- Company news
- Share tips
- A-Z company search
More share features
POPULAR Share Prices
- Royal Mail share price
- Lloyds share price
- HSBC share price
- Barclays share price
- Prudential share price
- Santander share price
- NEXT share price
- Diageo share price
- BP share price
- Vodafone share price
- British Airways
- Centrica share price
- Tesco share price
- Taylor Wimpey Share Price
- National Grid
- GKP Share Price
- Marks and Spencer
- Rolls Royce
- Rio Tinto
- THG Share Price
- Aviva Share Price
- Boil Share price
- Easyjet Share Price
- Genedrive Share Price
- SSE Share Price
- IAG Share Price
- Boohoo share price
- HE1 share price
- AVCT share price
- BOOM share price